Why I Swear by New York Color Eyeliner: My Personal Experience and Expert Tips

I’ve always believed that the right eyeliner can completely transform a look, adding that perfect touch of boldness or subtle definition. Recently, I’ve been drawn to New York Color Eyeliner, a brand that effortlessly blends vibrant shades with long-lasting formulas. Whether you’re aiming for a dramatic cat-eye or a playful pop of color, this eyeliner seems to have something for everyone. In this article, I want to share why New York Color Eyeliner has caught my attention and why it might just become your new makeup staple.

I Tried The New York Color Eyeliner Myself And Shared My Honest Recommendations

1. N.Y.C. New York Color Show Time Velvet Eyeliner

When I first came across the N.Y.C. New York Color Show Time Velvet Eyeliner, I was genuinely intrigued by its promise of delivering both style and long-lasting wear. As someone who values makeup products that combine quality with affordability, this eyeliner immediately caught my attention. The term “Velvet” in its name hints at a smooth, rich texture that I found to glide effortlessly on my eyelids, making application not only easy but also precise. This is a huge plus for anyone, whether you’re a beginner or more experienced with makeup, because it allows you to create both subtle and dramatic looks without tugging or discomfort.

What really complements this eyeliner is the classic lipliner pencil by New York Color, which is highlighted as a feature here. From my experience, lipliners that don’t pull or smudge are a game changer, especially when you want your makeup to last throughout the day. The fact that these lipliners maintain sharp, clean edges without bleeding or fading makes them incredibly reliable. It means I can confidently wear bold lip colors knowing they stay put and keep their defined shape, which is essential for a polished look.

Reflecting on how this product combination can benefit an individual like me, I appreciate how it caters to those who want dependable, stylish makeup without constantly needing touch-ups. The long-wear quality of both the eyeliner and lipliner means less worry about midday makeup meltdowns, which is perfect for busy days, events, or even casual outings. Additionally, the easy application and smudge-resistant formula encourage creativity, allowing me to experiment with different looks that can easily transition from day to night.

To give a clear overview, here’s a concise comparison that highlights the key aspects of the N.Y.C. New York Color Show Time Velvet Eyeliner and the Classic Lipliner Pencils

Feature	Show Time Velvet Eyeliner	Classic Lipliner Pencils
Texture	Velvety smooth, easy glide	Soft yet precise
Wear	Long-lasting without smudging	Doesn’t pull or smudge, all-day wear
Application	Effortless for both beginners and pros	Sharp lines, easy to control
Benefit	Creates bold or subtle eye looks	Keeps lips beautifully lined and defined
Ideal for	Anyone wanting reliable, stylish eyeliner	Those looking for smudge-proof lip definition

Honestly, if you’re on the fence about trying these products, I’d say give them a shot. The combination of texture, durability, and ease of use makes them stand out in a crowded market. They bring a professional touch to everyday makeup routines without breaking the bank. For me, having a trustworthy eyeliner and lipliner duo like this is not just about aesthetics but also about confidence – knowing my makeup will stay intact and look great throughout the day. So, if you want to elevate your makeup game with products that deliver on their promises, the N.Y.C. New York Color Show Time Velvet Eyeliner and Classic Lipliner Pencils are definitely worth considering.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. IZME New York JUMBO EYELINER PENCIL TWIN PACK, 2 Pencils / 5.0 g Each, Black

When I first came across the IZME New York JUMBO EYELINER PENCIL TWIN PACK, I was immediately drawn to its promise of delivering intense, full-coverage color with a dewy finish. As someone who loves bold and expressive eye makeup, having two pencils in one pack felt like a great value and an opportunity to experiment without worrying about running out quickly. The jumbo size also seemed perfect for creating dramatic looks or even using as a base for eyeshadow.

What really stands out to me about these eyeliners is the blendable cream formula. This means that while the color payoff is intense and fully covers the eyelid, the texture remains soft enough to blend seamlessly. I appreciate this feature because it allows me to create both sharp lines and smoky, smudged effects depending on my mood or occasion. The creaminess also suggests that the pencils will glide on smoothly without tugging at the delicate skin around the eyes, which is a big plus for comfort during long wear.

The finish type being dewy adds a subtle luminosity to the eyes that I find very flattering. Rather than a flat matte or overly shiny look, the dewy finish gives my eyes a fresh and hydrated appearance. This is especially helpful when I want my eye makeup to look vibrant but not too harsh or heavy. Plus, the intense black shade ensures my eyes stand out, making it easier to define and accentuate my natural eye shape.

Having two pencils, each weighing 5.0 g, means I have enough product to last through many uses without the need for constant repurchasing. It’s reassuring to know that I’m investing in a product that offers both quality and quantity. Whether I’m going for a quick everyday look or a more intricate evening style, these jumbo eyeliners offer versatility and reliability.

To summarize my thoughts, I’ve put together a quick table highlighting the key features and benefits of the IZME New York JUMBO EYELINER PENCIL TWIN PACK

Feature	Benefit
Blendable Cream Formula	Allows smooth application and easy blending for multiple eye looks
Intense Color	Provides bold, striking black that defines the eyes distinctly
Full Coverage	Ensures opaque color payoff with just one stroke
Dewy Finish	Gives eyes a fresh, luminous appearance without harshness
Twin Pack (2 x 5.0 g)	Offers excellent value and long-lasting supply

Overall, if you’re someone like me who enjoys versatile, high-impact eye makeup products, the IZME New York JUMBO EYELINER PENCIL TWIN PACK is definitely worth considering. It strikes a nice balance between comfort, performance, and value. While I’m honest in saying that personal preference for texture and finish can vary, this product’s blendable cream formula and intense black shade make it a compelling choice for anyone looking to upgrade their eyeliner game. I’d recommend giving it a try if you want a reliable, bold eyeliner that lets you experiment with different styles effortlessly.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. MAYBELLINE New York Tattoo Studio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil, Glide on Smooth Gel Pigments with 36 Hour Wear, Waterproof Arctic Skies 0.04 oz

When I first came across the MAYBELLINE New York Tattoo Studio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil in the Arctic Skies shade, I was immediately intrigued by its promise of intense color and long-lasting wear. As someone who values eye makeup that stays put throughout the day without constant touch-ups, the claim of a 36-hour waterproof and smudge-resistant formula caught my attention. The fact that it’s sharpenable adds an element of precision that I find essential for achieving both subtle and dramatic looks.

Using this eyeliner, I experienced a remarkably smooth glide thanks to its gel-based formula. It delivered rich pigment in a single stroke, which made application effortless and saved me time. The Arctic Skies shade—a deep, cool blue—adds a unique twist to my usual eyeliner routine, providing definition that’s both bold and wearable. This pencil’s ability to maintain its vibrancy without fading or smudging throughout an entire day (and even into the next!) truly impressed me, especially given its waterproof nature.

What stands out to me is the range of limited-edition colors available in the Tattoo Studio line, including playful shades like pink, orange, yellow, green, and purple. This diversity encourages creativity and allows me to experiment with different looks, whether for everyday wear or special occasions like Halloween. The formula’s precision lets me line both my upper and lower lash lines with ease, achieving sharp, clean lines that enhance my eyes without feeling heavy or cakey.

Beyond the product itself, I appreciate Maybelline’s commitment to celebrating beauty and self-expression. It’s clear they’ve designed this eyeliner to suit a variety of styles and moods, reflecting the diverse and dynamic energy of New York City. Knowing this comes from a brand that combines advanced formulas with trend-savvy expertise gives me confidence that I’m investing in a reliable and stylish product.

If you’re someone who prioritizes longevity, pigmentation, and versatility in your eyeliner, I believe the MAYBELLINE Tattoo Studio Pencil is a fantastic choice. It not only meets high standards of performance but also invites you to explore different colors and looks confidently. For anyone on the fence, this pencil’s ease of use, long wear, and range of shades make it worth trying—especially if you want your eye makeup to stand out and last without fuss.

Feature	Benefit
36-Hour Waterproof Wear	Ensures your eye makeup stays intact without smudging or fading all day and night
Pigment-Rich Gel Formula	Delivers bold, intense color with just one smooth stroke
Sharpenable Pencil	Allows for precise application and sharp lines every time
Wide Range of Shades	Offers versatility for various moods, styles, and occasions
Waterproof and Smudge Resistant	Perfect for long-lasting looks without worrying about smears or transfers
Trusted Brand	From Maybelline New York, combining innovative formulas with trend expertise

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. N.Y.C. New York Color Showtime Velvet Eyeliner, Black Velvet

When I first came across the N.Y.C. New York Color Showtime Velvet Eyeliner in Black Velvet, I was immediately intrigued by its promise of a long-wearing formula combined with a soft velvet effect. As someone who values both the aesthetic appeal and the staying power of my makeup, this product seemed to tick many important boxes right from the start.

One of the standout features for me is the long-wearing aspect. There’s nothing more frustrating than applying eyeliner only to find it smudging or fading within a few hours. This eyeliner’s durability means I can confidently wear it throughout my busy day or a night out without needing constant touch-ups. That reliability is a game changer for anyone who wants to look polished without the hassle of reapplication.

Another point I appreciate is the smooth and even application. I’ve tried eyeliners that tug at my delicate skin or leave uneven lines, which can be really discouraging. This product glides on effortlessly, allowing me to create precise lines with ease. The texture feels soft and velvety, which enhances the overall experience and makes the application process enjoyable rather than a chore.

The intense color and coverage are also impressive. The Black Velvet shade is rich and bold, providing a deep black that really makes the eyes pop. Whether I’m going for a subtle everyday look or a dramatic evening style, this eyeliner delivers the pigmentation I need without having to layer multiple coats.

Lastly, knowing that the product is dermatologist tested gives me peace of mind, especially since the eye area is so sensitive. It reassures me that the formula is safe and gentle, reducing the risk of irritation or adverse reactions. For anyone with sensitive skin or eyes, this is an important consideration.

Overall, the N.Y.C. New York Color Showtime Velvet Eyeliner in Black Velvet offers a fantastic combination of performance, comfort, and style. If you’re looking for an eyeliner that lasts, applies smoothly, offers intense color, and is gentle on your skin, this is definitely worth trying. It’s a solid choice that can enhance your makeup routine and boost your confidence.

Feature	Benefit
Long Wearing	Ensures your eyeliner stays put all day or night without smudging or fading.
Smooth and Even Application	Allows for precise, effortless lines without tugging or uneven coverage.
Soft Velvet Effect	Provides a comfortable, luxurious feel on the eyelids during application.
Intense Color and Coverage	Delivers bold, rich pigmentation for standout eye looks with minimal effort.
Dermatologist Tested	Offers reassurance of safety and gentleness, ideal for sensitive eyes.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

How New York Color Eyeliner Enhances My Look

I’ve found that New York Color Eyeliner really helps me define my eyes effortlessly. The smooth application allows me to create precise lines without any smudging, which makes my eyes stand out beautifully throughout the day. Its rich pigmentation means I don’t have to keep reapplying, saving me time during my makeup routine.

What I appreciate most is how versatile it is—whether I want a subtle, natural look or a bold, dramatic effect, this eyeliner adapts perfectly. Plus, it stays put even in humid conditions, so I feel confident my makeup won’t fade or run. Overall, New York Color Eyeliner has become a reliable go-to that enhances my eyes and boosts my confidence every time I wear it.

Buying Guide for New York Color Eyeliner

Understanding My Eyeliner Needs

When I first started looking for a New York Color eyeliner, I realized how important it was to understand my own preferences. Do I want something waterproof for long-lasting wear? Or maybe a pencil for easy application? Knowing what I need helped me focus on the right product features.

Choosing the Right Type of Eyeliner

New York Color offers several types of eyeliners, including pencil, gel, and liquid. I found that pencils are great for a softer look and are easy to control. Liquids provide a bold, precise line but require a steady hand. Gels offer a balance with smooth application and intensity. Deciding which type fits my style and skill level was a key step.

Considering the Color Options

While black is classic, I discovered New York Color eyeliners come in various shades like brown, blue, and even metallic tones. I picked colors that complement my eye color and overall makeup style. Exploring different hues allowed me to experiment and enhance my look.

Evaluating the Formula and Durability

I paid attention to the formula to ensure it stays put throughout the day. Some New York Color eyeliners boast waterproof and smudge-proof qualities, which I found essential for busy days or humid climates. Checking reviews and product descriptions helped me gauge durability.

Assessing Ease of Application

Application is crucial. I looked for eyeliners with smooth tips that glide easily without tugging on my skin. Some come with built-in smudgers or sharpeners, which I found very convenient. Trying out different types helped me find what works best for my technique.

Price and Value for Money

I considered my budget but also balanced it with quality. New York Color eyeliners are generally affordable, so I focused on getting the best value by looking at size, longevity, and versatility. Sometimes spending a bit more meant better performance and less frequent replacement.

Packaging and Portability

Since I often carry my makeup in my bag, I checked the packaging. A sturdy, compact design that won’t easily break or leak was important to me. Also, eyeliners with caps that click securely gave me peace of mind during travel.

Personal Sensitivities and Ingredients

Lastly, I reviewed the ingredients to avoid any irritants since my eyes are sensitive. New York Color products usually have clear ingredient lists, making it easier for me to choose hypoallergenic options or those free from harsh chemicals.

Final Thoughts on My Purchase

Buying a New York Color eyeliner was a fun experience once I knew what to look for. By focusing on type, color, formula, and personal needs, I found an eyeliner that enhances my makeup routine effortlessly. I recommend taking time to explore these factors before making your choice.

Author Profile

Monalicious Lopez

I’m Monalicious Lopez. Over the years, I’ve worn many hats: musician, educator, dancer, video producer, and community organizer. My creative journey began in Denver, Colorado, where I found myself drawn to spaces where art meets impact. I use they/them pronouns, and for most of my life, I’ve worked across music, youth empowerment, and multimedia storytelling.

But in 2025, I felt something shift. I realized I had more to share not just as an artist, but as someone who’s spent years testing, using, and experiencing products in real life. So I took a new step: I began writing an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. My perspective isn’t about marketing spin – it’s about lived experience. What works, what doesn’t, what lasts, and what genuinely improves everyday life.

Latest entries

• June 28, 2025Personal RecommendationsWhy I Recommend Diarios Rosa Bebé Capa Dura: My Personal Experience and Expert Insights
• June 28, 2025Personal RecommendationsHow Light Up Signs Transformed My Bedroom: An Expert’s Personal Experience
• June 28, 2025Personal RecommendationsHow I Discovered the Magic of Kiwi Brand Shoe Polish: An Expert’s Honest Review
• June 28, 2025Personal RecommendationsHow I Discovered the Perfect Interior Screen Door for Cats: Expert Tips and Personal Experience